Norway’s pioneering 2003 legislation demanding that listed companies’ executive boards be made up of at least 40 percent women has made female executives more prosperous. And that’s about it.

In a radical move, Norway became the first country in the world to require that a minimum number of board seats in public limited companies be filled by women. At that time, only 9 percent of board directors were female. The mandate attracted global attention and has inspired other countries to adopt similar measures. It seemed a natural fit for Norway, where the prime minister and finance minister are both female and where women lead two of the  important economic actors: the Confederation of Norwegian Business and Industry and the Norwegian Confederation of Trade Unions.

In the 12 years since the legislation was enacted, researchers all over the world have studied Norway’s corporate climate in order to analyze the effects the legislation has had. Recently, the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research concluded that one of the effects of the law is more and better-paid female executives. But the report found no significant effect on the number of female managers below the executive level.

Surprisingly, other research indicates that companies that have adopted the 40 percent rule have seen negative effects, including lower market value and profitability, slower adaptation to changing market conditions, and even a tendency to favor more men in midlevel leadership positions. A series of global studies suggest that greater female representation in senior management results in fewer female midlevel managers. It turns out that when women recruit, they hire more men and fewer women.

Furthermore, researchers have uncovered negative effects of gender quotas on the bottom line. Marius Apland Johansen and Marius Javier Sandnes showed in 2008 that Norwegian companies that had introduced gender quotas saw a decrease of just under 2 percent in their valuation. Similarly, Kenneth Ahern and Amy K. Dittmar’s 2012 article in the Quarterly Journal of Economics showed that Norwegian companies adhering to the quota experienced an immediate sharp drop in stock value followed by a large decrease in Tobin’s Q Ratio—a measure of whether market value is consistent with the real value of the company. They suggested that the quota led to younger and less experienced boards, increases in debt and acquisitions, and deterioration in operating performance. Affected firms undertook fewer workforce reductions than other companies, increasing relative labor costs and employment levels and reducing short-term profits.

Norway’s law hasn’t had a gender-leveling effect on non-board salaries either. While women’s pay has risen, men’s wages have risen even more. Wage inequality is as wide as before—and in top-level positions, it is actually wider.

It may seem puzzling that these legal measures have had so little positive effect. The premise the law builds on is that diversity is profitable. And it usually is. Why not here?

When strategies are forced upon the corporate world by lawmakers, culture deeply rooted in traditions opposes change. An additional time lag might have occurred due to the fact that the executive talent pipeline was not fully prepared for such a top-down approach.

At HR Norge, we believe that it’s a matter of culture, logistics and process for change. When strategies are forced upon the corporate world by lawmakers, culture deeply rooted in traditions opposes change. An additional time lag might have occurred due to the fact that the executive talent pipeline was not fully prepared for such a topdown approach.

Nevertheless, companies that voluntarily promote diversity generally are much more profitable than their less diversified competitors. McKinsey’s study of 180 listed companies in France, Great Britain, Germany and the United States during 2008-2010 focused on two groups that are easy to identify as indicators of diversity—the proportion of women and the proportion of foreign nationals among top leaders in the company. McKinsey found what it referred to as “strikingly consistent findings”: Companies in the top quartile of board diversity had a 53 percent higher return on equity capital than those in the bottom fourth. Profit on earnings (before interest and tax) was 14 percent higher.

Perplexing questions remain. Intuition and experience should predict the positive effects of more women in senior management, but one research report after the other shows that the hard facts can’t justify the assumption. For diversity enthusiasts, this may be a bit discouraging. But don’t panic.

In “The Next Super Model,” The Economist’s fall 2013 special report about Nordic countries, Nordic success was shown to be valuedriven—in other words, based on “soft” factors. Our direct experience also shows that a deliberate diversity strategy can have a dramatically positive impact. Quotas just don’t seem to be the way to maximize the benefits of a diverse workforce.


EAPM Worldlink Mar 2015

Paal Leveraas was at the time of writing this a writer/journalist and senior advisor for communications at HR Norge, the Norwegian HR association.

This article was written for and published in the March 2015 issue of the WorldLink newsletter from European Association for People Management (EAPM).

Image – Women in a boat – by lbokel from Pixabay


Mer om mangfold

Milads valg

Milads valg

Jeg har ingen foiler. Ingen papirer. Men jeg gjør det en leder må gjøre i dag: jeg snakker fra hjertet ...
Om mangfold og å holde barnehjerter i hendene

Om mangfold og å holde barnehjerter i hendene

Alle de rare folka. Alle de hardtarbeidende menneskene. De selger krydder og munnstykker, holder barnehjerter, og nikker og smiler med ...
Det eneste som betyr noe for mangfold

Det eneste som betyr noe for mangfold

Det handler ikke om hudfarge, kjønn, alder og funksjonsgrad. Det spiller ingen rolle om du er ung eller gammel, svart eller ...
De som bygger det nye Norge

De som bygger det nye Norge

For 30 år siden var en gründer synonymt med en svindler. For 20 år siden var en gründer en spekulant ...
Loading...

 



Denne artikkelen er skrevet for en partner på innholdsproduksjon, og er vanligvis originalt publisert i kundens egne kanaler. Gjengitt her etter avtale. Her er noen flere slike artikler.

Gründerens bakdør til offentlig sektor

Gründerens bakdør til offentlig sektor

At anbudsreglene bygger motorveier for etablerte aktører og kostbare bomveier for nye er en mer eller mindre etablert sannhet. Et nytt ... les mer
Talenter i spill

Talenter i spill

Telenor har plassert 147 av sine aller beste kort på 'spilleduken' for å fylle vakuumet etter de 200 ansatte som ... les mer
Det er smart å bruke 18 måneder på onboarding

Det er smart å bruke 18 måneder på onboarding

Halvparten av enkelte typer ansettelser mislykkes. Det koster virksomhetene blod og tårer. Hvorfor er det sånn? Talya Bauer svarer ... les mer
Lisa Vivoll Straume

Doktor i positivitet: — Velvære er ikke nok. Du trenger litt strevsom lykke også

— Positiv psykologi handler ikke om å tenke positivt. Negative tanker og følelser er avgjørende for et velfungerende liv, men ... les mer
Forskere: Lederutvikling virker. Ikke

Forskere: Lederutvikling virker. Ikke

Glem Big Five, 360-målinger og IQ-tester. Mål heller den potensielle nye lederens hjerterytmevariasjon og skann hjernen. Det forteller deg mye ... les mer
En doktorand i alkohol skapte bølger i Making Waves. Det forandret alt for HR-direktør Hans Olav Hellem

En doktorand i alkohol skapte bølger i Making Waves. Det forandret alt for HR-direktør Hans Olav Hellem

Den ene har 400 indre motiverte ansatte med etterspurt kompetanse. Den andre tar doktorgrad på alkoholisme. Nå var de på ... les mer
Bærekraft, IS og (veldig) Sterk strøm

Bærekraft, IS og (veldig) Sterk strøm

Som student tok han ekstrajobb i Telenor. Snart var han globalt ansvarlig for samfunnsansvar. Senere drev han vannkraft i Tyrkia ... les mer
Blind digital rekrutterer valgte 50% flere kvinner

Blind digital rekrutterer valgte 50% flere kvinner

Den digitale rekruttereren visste ikke navn, kjønn, etnisitet eller alder. Det ga voldsomme utslag på resultatene av rekrutteringen ... les mer
Josh Brand

8 egenskaper ledere trenger i vår komplekse verden

Lær hvordan du lærer lederne dine å lære i en verden hvor man må lære hele tiden. Din lærer for ... les mer
Loading...

 

Alltid på en tirsdag

«Jeg har fått en slags tirsdagsforventning», sa en abonnent. Og ja, Tirsdag morgen er antagelig en smule vanedannende, men gode vaner kan man gjerne legge tll seg. Skaff deg selv en god ukentlig vane i dag — rett i din innboks! Alltid på en tirsdag, men aldri ellers i uka.

Fantastisk! Sjekk mailen din for en ekstra bekreftelse. Så ses vi på tirsdag.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This